Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
Shop deviantART for the
holidays and save BIG!
Click here! :holly:
[x]

deviantART

 

Mature Content System "Upgrades"

Thu Oct 18, 2007, 1:16 PM
  • Mood: Rant
  • Listening to: The voices in my head.
  • Reading: $realitysquared's Journal
  • Watching: dA go down the tubes.
  • Playing: With words.
  • Eating: Apple with peanut butter.
  • Drinking: Mineral water
According to [link] , the Mature Content system has been subjected to an "upgrade". As someone who routinely views deviations with the Mature Content tag[0], I strongly object to deviantART's new blanket age restriction on Mature Content.

As $realitysquared[1] states in his journal, "In my personal opinion the sole purpose of a Mature Content filtering system is to keep the tagged content away from underage users."

I disagree.

Though it is[2] illegal for minors to be exposed to pornographic content, deviantART purports to police its galleries of such adult material.

The Mature Content filter as it was, therefore, was a division merely between those who preferred to avoid such content and those who sought it. It made no distinction as to whom should be restricted from viewing mature content, simply because it was not, I assumed, deviantART's place to instate policies that are crafted according to what people should do or should think.

Apparently I was wrong.

But the new Mature Content filter slays a large portion of the community that would view and provide valuable critique for adult content of what is — or most definitely should be — purely artistic in nature.

The new system is, in this respect, destructive. It is destructive to the already failing community that is deviantART, a community that professes to be one where artists can share and critique to better themselves and one another, but whose actual impression is one increasingly like MySpace.

The majority of people who view genuinely artistic mature content (and I refer here to visual content) outside an artistic context are too ignorant to realise that it is not pornography; these people should not be members of deviantART in the first place, and hence should be disallowed from viewing mature content.[3]

An age restriction on the mature content filtration system is detrimental to the health of the community, simply because it is an arbitrary restriction.

I rest my case.

[0] For both artistic inspiration and anatomy reference
[1] A deviant whom I respect and admire greatly
[2] I will not say "should be"
[3] If you want an example of a real art community, take a look at PixelJoint.

Devious Comments

love 0 0 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconkaiseto:
Can you favorite articles? =D

You know my thoughts on this. I couldn't have expressed them nearly so well as you have.

--
And then, for a solitary, fleeting moment, the universe was absolutely, perfectly silent

As if muted in awe
:icont4kumi:
The majority of deviantART is, I'm guessing, 15-30-ish. This "new update," in my opinion, is useless. As you said, at first, we could choose to be able to view mature arts or not. They might as well get rid of mature content, like SheezyART.

P.S.: 'Sup man, haven't heard from you in a while :P

--
[link]
Join the Thirteen Hearts Forum ^__^ ==>[link]
| *writersdA | ~GmodClub |
:iconshiznitzle:
Well said and well deserved.

--
./) /) Whatever tickles your inner critter
( . .)
c(")(")
:iconjaraiya-on-crack:
I agree with you entirly.

--
I reject your reality and substitute "=)" my own!!!!!!!
"Don't move...I think I just failed a spot check."
"Roll to see if you see that giant spider ahead!"
Du bist kaum eine Person.
~AdvertiseYou, ~WritersClub
:iconevincarofautumn:
Thanks. :D

--
As a courtesy to foreign members of dA, I try to speak in the native language of every artist on whose work I comment. I do my best on my own, but often I need to make use of online translators to assist me, so I apologise in advance for my mistakes!
:iconevincarofautumn:
Thank you.

--
As a courtesy to foreign members of dA, I try to speak in the native language of every artist on whose work I comment. I do my best on my own, but often I need to make use of online translators to assist me, so I apologise in advance for my mistakes!
:iconevincarofautumn:
Ugh. I almost don't want to say it, but SheezyART is getting ready to surpass dA.

...and long time no see. :D

--
As a courtesy to foreign members of dA, I try to speak in the native language of every artist on whose work I comment. I do my best on my own, but often I need to make use of online translators to assist me, so I apologise in advance for my mistakes!
:iconevincarofautumn:
Thanks.

--
As a courtesy to foreign members of dA, I try to speak in the native language of every artist on whose work I comment. I do my best on my own, but often I need to make use of online translators to assist me, so I apologise in advance for my mistakes!

Journal History

Site Map